bookpile.gif (2960 bytes) Tethtoril's Bookshelf bookpile.gif (2960 bytes)

Reviews Index

"This is where we keep all the scrolls which travelers pen themselves, telling us of their thoughts on certain items of the Realms", whispered the Scribe. Indeed this collection of scrolls was carefully organized and stored according to their titles, each one also listing the author.  Just as you thought that there would be not a single inch to place another scroll, a scribe walks in through a stone archway in the northeastern corner of the room carrying a bundle of sealed scrolls in his arms and places them in a seemingly bottomless casket next to a desk, 'how many more scrolls could this place hold?' you silently ask yourself".

This page contains a list of all reviews submitted by visitors to Candlekeep.  All entries are listed in alphabetical order for easy access to a particular product.  If you wish to submit your own review please enter The Scribe's Desk and tell all of what you think of a Forgotten Realms product.   Anyone can submit a review and don't be put off if a product has been reviewed by many others, everyone has an opinion so feel free to tell people yours. 
Enter your review at
Sit at the Scribes Desk

Be warned: Some reviews may contain "spoilers" and can give some of the plot away in their comments!

Should you have any questions or queries, please Contact us.


Orbs of Rating

Ratings on the product pages are indicated by scrying devices (as shown below and on the 'Scribe's Desk' page).

Poor
Average
Good
Very Good
Excellent!

Scrolls of Review

Product Reviewed
Reviewer
Date
Azure Bonds Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
  Mike G Jordan
06-August-2000
Baldurs Gate (Computer Game) Andrew Garnett
10-June-2000
  Archmage George
18-November-2002
Baldurs Gate (Novel) Mike G Jordan
06-August-2000
Baldurs Gate II: Shadows of Amn (computer game) Troy Roberts
09-September-2001
  Darok of Albana
09-September-2001
Beyond the High Road Carl Reyes
19-December-1999
  Jonathan Burness
06-August-2000
Black Wolf Jeremy Daw
09-March-2004
Bloodstone Pass Marc
30-January-2000
  Phil Tarring
09-May-2001
Canticle Gaelan Kent
14-August-2000
City of Splendors Duniya
13-September-2000
Cormyr: A Novel Mike G Jordan
12-May-2000
  Rob ZumBrunnen
08-May-2004
Crown of Fire Silver Huntress
05-November-2002
Darkwalker on Moonshae Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
  Jonathan Burness
10-June-2000
  Paul Gotts
20-May-2001
Daughter of the Drow Rebecca
20-February-2000
Death of the Dragon Mike G Jordan
14-August-2000
Dissolution Dan
05-November-2002
Elfshadow Reyland Nepomuceno
01-January-2003
ElfSong John Smith
14-September-2003
Elminster in Hell Mike G Jordan
09-September-2001
  William Burleson
21-September-2001
  Henrik Harksen
21-September-2001
  Chris McDonald
14-September-2003
Elminster in Myth Drannor Chris McDonald
14-September-2003
Elminster: The Making of a Mage Brandon Gibson
08-July-2001
  Aaron Farrell
04-August-2003
  Chris McDonald
14-September-2003
  Elric
19-February-2006
Elves of Evermeet Duniya
25-July-1999
Evermeet: Island of Elves Colin Fesser
06-August-2000
  Chance Walling
17-December-2003
Faces of Deception Reyland Nepomuceno
01-January-2003
  Jeremy Daw
15-April-2004
Forgotten Realms Atlas CD-ROM Jason L Redfern
14-November-1999
Four from Cormyr Glenn Davis 19-November-2006
Giantcraft Vanisher
19-February-2006
Heirs of Prophecy Jeremy Daw
15-April-2004
Homeland NewDle
08-May-2004
  Ron Fernandes
18-July-2004
Horselords Jason L Redfern
09-September-1999
Icewind Dale (Computer Game) Logan
15-October-2000
  Mike G Jordan
29-October-2000
In Sylvan Shadows Jason L Redfern
09-September-1999
  Gaelan Kent
14-August-2000
King Pinch Roman Kalik
19-February-2006
Menzoberranzan Duniya
18-July-1999
  J6G
18-March-2001
Neverwinter Nights (computer game) Kaervok
17-December-2003
Night Masks Gaelan Kent
14-August-2000
Once around the Realms Mike G Jordan
12-May-2000
Pirates of the Fallen Stars Duniya
08-August-1999
Pool of Radiance Nicholas Faubert
09-September-2001
Pool of Twilight Jonathan Burness
06-August-2000
Prince of Lies Jonathan Burness
13-September-2000
Realms of Shadow Juan Basso
28-January-2004
Rising Tide Jason L Redfern
18-May-1999
  Adam Coakley
19-February-2006
Sea of Swords H. Achtrichtes
17-December-2003
Servant of the Shard Mike G Jordan
12-November-2000
  H. Achtrichtes
17-December-2003
Shadowdale Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
  Elric
19-February-2006

Shadows of Doom

Geoffrey Phillips
27-February-2003
Shadows Witness Rad
18-September-2002
Silverfall: Stories of the Seven Sisters Mike G Jordan
13-September-2000
Stormlight Justin E. Salisbury
26-March-2000
Streams of Silver Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
Sojourn John Smith
14-September-2003
Spellfire Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
Duniya
22-August-1999
T.D. Paulat
01-August-1999
  Justin Tooker
17-October-1999
  Mike G Jordan
12-May-2000
  Jonathan Burness
06-August-2000
  James Zobac
18-March-2001
Tangled Webs Mike G Jordan
06-August-2002
  Dan
05-November-2002
Tantras Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
Temple Hill Scott Terrett
14-September-2003
The Bloodstone Wars Marc
30-January-2000
  Phil Tarring
09-May-2001
The City of Ravens Scott Terrett
14-September-2003
The Crystal Shard Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
The Fallen Fortress Aaron
18-July-2004
The Floodgate Mike G Jordan
08-July-2001
The Halflings Gem Brett Franklin
12-July-1999
The Lost LIbrary of Cormanthyr Ghaundar T' Sarran
04-August-2003
The Magehound Robert Sullivan
08-April-2000
  Mike G Jordan
11-June-2000
The Mines of Bloodstone Marc
30-January-2000
  Phil Tarring
09-May-2001
The Nether Scroll Julian Matson
22-August-2004
The Parched Sea Dan
05-November-2002
The Ruins of Myth Drannor Duniya
25-July-1999
The Seige Mike G Jordan
06-December-2001
The Shadow Stone Mike G Jordan
06-December-2001
  Dale Bettridge
09-March-2004
The Silent Blade Matías Laíno
10-March-2002
The Sorcerer John Smith
14-September-2003
The Spine of the World H. Achtrichtes
17-December-2003
The Summoning Mike G Jordan
09-April-2001
The Temptation of Elminster Chris McDonald
14-September-2003
The Throne of Bloodstone Jane Hammond
18-January-2000
Marc
30-January-2000
  Phil Tarring
09-May-2001
The Veiled Dragon Jason L Redfern
09-September-1999
Villains Lorebook Gabriel Gabbardo
26-May-2000
Waterdeep Brett Franklin
12-July-1999

Enter your review at the Scribes Desk

Go to Tethtoril's Bookshelf

Go to the Home Page