| Author |
Topic  |
|
Aryalómë
Senior Scribe
  
USA
666 Posts |
Posted - 11 May 2013 : 15:12:34
|
I downloaded an Excel document from the Planescape forums that listed over 1200 deities. I got curious to find certain types of deities, so I ctrl + f'ed and started searching. I got onto looking for deities of men and, out of all 1200+ deities, not a single one of them were deities of men or guardian of men or anything (save for Vhaeraun and Keptolo, but those are Drow deities).
I got extremely annoyed by this. There were several deities for women, but none for men. Why is D&D so sexist like this?
Isn't there a deity, or, at the very least, any kind of organization that is made up solely of male figures because of some kind of doctrine? I'm not interested in any Drow things (that is, Drow things that concern FR) because they have been driven into the ground.
|
|
|
TheHermit
Seeker

USA
60 Posts |
Posted - 11 May 2013 : 16:39:53
|
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë I got extremely annoyed by this. There were several deities for women, but none for men. Why is D&D so sexist like this?
Poe's Law in full effect. |
- "Glitz & Klax's Potions & Elixirs"/"The Sandmen", Inside Ravens Bluff, The Living City; 1990; TSR, Inc. - "The Far Guardians' Traveler's Mission", Port of Ravens Bluff; 1991, TSR, Inc. - "Signs Painted", Polyhedron #70; April, 1992; TSR, Inc. - Communications Director, Coliseum of Comics, Orlando, FL - http://coliseumofcomics.com/ |
 |
|
|
Markustay
Realms Explorer extraordinaire
    
USA
15724 Posts |
Posted - 11 May 2013 : 17:23:33
|
@TheHermit - Not sure if you are addressing the topic, or the topic's poster (after Wiki'ing "Poes Law").
Anyhow - this goes WAY BACK (as in "caveman days") to the concept that women are weak and need protection, and men can 'fend For themselves'. Obviously this is a relic from our own real world, and really doesn't belong in FR (or any other fantasy world where women have always been considered 'equals'). Unfortunately, we can't hire authors/designers from other worlds, so we are stuck with all these preconceptions (because unless you are consciously aware of what you are doing, you can't 'not do it').
For instance, I had never even thought about this before, as I am sure no-one else has either. We can 'fix it' now that its been brought to our attention, but the simple fact that things like this exist for years without anyone noticing just shows us how steeped in our own preconceptions we are. We are completely unaware that there is anything wrong.
I'm still not sure, however, that anything actually IS wrong... which just means I am also a victim of my own preconceptions. For example, I am a 'fat old guy', and I am quite perturbed there is no deity for 'fat old guys'. I am incensed, and think that WotC is extremely prejudice against 'fat old guys' (which is weird... considering what I saw at Gencon...)
Yes... that was my own example of my newly acquired knowledge of the concept of 'Poes Law' (so yes, I was being sarcastic... or making a parody.. or something...) |
"I have never in my life learned anything from any man who agreed with me" --- Dudley Field Malone
|
Edited by - Markustay on 11 May 2013 17:24:06 |
 |
|
|
Wooly Rupert
Master of Mischief

    
USA
36974 Posts |
Posted - 12 May 2013 : 05:13:16
|
| So you're complaining that D&D is sexist, but then asking about organizations that specifically exclude women? Isn't that sexist, in and of itself? |
Candlekeep Forums Moderator
Candlekeep - The Library of Forgotten Realms Lore http://www.candlekeep.com -- Candlekeep Forum Code of Conduct
I am the Giant Space Hamster of Ill Omen!  |
 |
|
|
Markustay
Realms Explorer extraordinaire
    
USA
15724 Posts |
Posted - 12 May 2013 : 13:59:10
|
Misguided liberalism at its finest.
Once you create any law/ruling that has to protect a specific group, you are then singling it out, which is the worst kind of prejudice.
I was just a kid back in the 70's, but even then I knew that certain parts of affirmative action were SO insanely biased against the very people they had to protect (like lowering the test grade scores needed on Police tests for 'persons of color', or lowering the strength/constitution requirements for women Firemen, etc). Once you single out any group and say "we need laws to protect them!", you are then (inadvertently) declaring that they are inferior, and need our protection.
Hey... lets call that "MarkusTay's Law". I always wanted my own law. 
So this seems related to that other thread about female leads, and stories about female characters. Yes, such things should be possible, but if you make it some sort of rule (with percentages and what-not) you are then forcing it upon the setting, and it becomes less natural. Concepts should grow out of the setting - and all things should be possible - but things should not be forced upon the setting simply because they are missing. So if an author/designer can come up with a story about such a deity and how it relates to FR - and its a good story - then by all means, at that point we should have one.
IMO, of course. |
"I have never in my life learned anything from any man who agreed with me" --- Dudley Field Malone
|
 |
|
|
Aryalómë
Senior Scribe
  
USA
666 Posts |
Posted - 12 May 2013 : 16:56:10
|
quote: Originally posted by Wooly Rupert
So you're complaining that D&D is sexist, but then asking about organizations that specifically exclude women? Isn't that sexist, in and of itself?
Not that it has to exclude women, but women have so much stuff that is exclusive to them it begins to chafe. Even races that are mostly women (which I read about today). Also, races that are supposed to be beautiful or very magically bent usually weaker and frail of body, which is clearly favoring a more feminine approach and aesthetic to it.
Why can't their be a god that favours men or a guardian of them? What makes women so special that they always get them and have special organizations or cults for them?
@Markustay; Affirmative Action is extremely prejudiced against people of European background mostly; especially European descended men. But let's not open that can of worms right now.
All I'm asking is why there can't be equal representation of both genders and let them have organizations for each other. I wonder if Ed's Realms are like this or if it's just something that mainstream fantasy likes to do. |
 |
|
|
Marc
Senior Scribe
  
662 Posts |
Posted - 13 May 2013 : 10:26:15
|
| Men have enough organizations, such as brotherhoods. In Pathfinder there's Erastil, who's old fashioned and thinks women belong in the kitchen. |
. |
 |
|
|
Markustay
Realms Explorer extraordinaire
    
USA
15724 Posts |
Posted - 13 May 2013 : 15:26:49
|
I'm sold.  |
"I have never in my life learned anything from any man who agreed with me" --- Dudley Field Malone
|
 |
|
|
MrHedgehog
Senior Scribe
  
688 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 02:01:09
|
I am sure if you looked at those deities that come from the real world many of them would only have male clerics. Deities would probably have different organizations with different rules... even different religious groups from the same deity that only allow one gender. There was a goddess worshiped by Romans named Cybele who they believed required her priests to be castrated, for example. (My friend is getting her PhD on Transgenderism in the ancient world)
If you COUNT the deities in the realms there are more male deities than female deities and they tend to be more powerful/important even with efforts to be equitable. In 4th edition there are eighteen greater deities. Females? Chauntea, Lolth, Selune, Shar and Sune. 5/18. Suggesting the realms has a preference for powerful females over males deities is absurd.
They probably don't feel the need to point out male only groups since readers, and perhaps the author, assume the majority of religious figures are male anyways. |
Edited by - MrHedgehog on 14 May 2013 02:03:49 |
 |
|
|
TheHermit
Seeker

USA
60 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 02:37:37
|
| #firstrealmsproblems |
- "Glitz & Klax's Potions & Elixirs"/"The Sandmen", Inside Ravens Bluff, The Living City; 1990; TSR, Inc. - "The Far Guardians' Traveler's Mission", Port of Ravens Bluff; 1991, TSR, Inc. - "Signs Painted", Polyhedron #70; April, 1992; TSR, Inc. - Communications Director, Coliseum of Comics, Orlando, FL - http://coliseumofcomics.com/ |
 |
|
|
Aryalómë
Senior Scribe
  
USA
666 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 11:55:53
|
| That's STILL not what I'm talking about, though. I don't want just a group who's just predominantly male, I want a group who is together for the same reason as the all female groups form. I mean, you don't even have a single prestige class that is for males only; it's all just heavily unfair and I'm extremely tired of it. |
 |
|
|
Wooly Rupert
Master of Mischief

    
USA
36974 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 13:16:04
|
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
That's STILL not what I'm talking about, though. I don't want just a group who's just predominantly male, I want a group who is together for the same reason as the all female groups form.
Because they've been overlooked, underestimated, oppressed, disrespected, and otherwise dismissed by the opposite gender?
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
I mean, you don't even have a single prestige class that is for males only; it's all just heavily unfair and I'm extremely tired of it.
So it's heavily unfair to have something exclusive to one gender, and the only way to make it fair is to continue perpetuating gender exclusion? |
Candlekeep Forums Moderator
Candlekeep - The Library of Forgotten Realms Lore http://www.candlekeep.com -- Candlekeep Forum Code of Conduct
I am the Giant Space Hamster of Ill Omen!  |
 |
|
|
Aryalómë
Senior Scribe
  
USA
666 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 14:50:51
|
quote: Originally posted by Wooly Rupert
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
That's STILL not what I'm talking about, though. I don't want just a group who's just predominantly male, I want a group who is together for the same reason as the all female groups form.
Because they've been overlooked, underestimated, oppressed, disrespected, and otherwise dismissed by the opposite gender?
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
I mean, you don't even have a single prestige class that is for males only; it's all just heavily unfair and I'm extremely tired of it.
So it's heavily unfair to have something exclusive to one gender, and the only way to make it fair is to continue perpetuating gender exclusion?
Ed himself said that women aren't treated as they are in the realms as they are here (and it's not even bad in te best places here), so there's NO reason they should have any special treatment that the opposite sex can't receive as well.
Are you advocating for one gender in the realms to have special things for them, but at the same time telling the other that they can't because...what? That's the thing. No one in te realms can't say them males can't have anything special for them because gender inequality is extremely rare in the realms.
Have things exclusive to each gender is a fair trade off for having one gender. Pearly favored over the other. |
 |
|
|
Wooly Rupert
Master of Mischief

    
USA
36974 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 17:54:35
|
No, I'm saying that complaining about gender exclusion and asking for more of it seems a bit odd. If something is bad, why do you want more of it?
It's also very ironic, because the usual complaint about sexism in fantasy is about how women are portrayed. |
Candlekeep Forums Moderator
Candlekeep - The Library of Forgotten Realms Lore http://www.candlekeep.com -- Candlekeep Forum Code of Conduct
I am the Giant Space Hamster of Ill Omen!  |
 |
|
|
Aldrick
Senior Scribe
  
909 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 18:16:18
|
quote: Originally posted by Markustay
Once you create any law/ruling that has to protect a specific group, you are then singling it out, which is the worst kind of prejudice.
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
@Markustay; Affirmative Action is extremely prejudiced against people of European background mostly; especially European descended men.
#Privilege

-------------
I'm going to pretend the above exchange didn't happen, and instead focus on answering your question. I have no idea if this is what you're talking about or not, and it certainly isn't canon. However, in my Realms the primary cult of Lathander in Chessenta is male only. They only accept male clergy and male members. Females can offer tribute to Lathander, but they can't be members of the cult.
Lathander is regarded as the deity of athletics, vitality, youth, and self-perfection in Chessenta. One of the things I wanted to do with Lathander in Chessenta - especially after the Amaunator heresy - was to differentiate his cult worship from the Heartlands and the North.
The male only part is a result of influence from the Mulan culture, tradition, and a huge admiration for the male body. Lathander is seen as the idealized form of male beauty. As characterized by Aristophanes a playwright of ancient Athens, the idealized male body was: "a gleaming chest, bright skin, broad shoulders, tiny tongue, strong buttocks, and a little prick." Statues of Lathander, which can be found pretty much in every city in Chessenta, reflect these preferences.
Chessenta is heavily inspired by ancient Greek culture, and I attempted to infuse it with a number of different elements from that culture. Canonically, athletics, wrestling in particular, is very important and popular culturally. The wrestling is done in the nude as it was done in ancient Greece. As the link points out the word Gymnasium comes from the Ancient Greek term gymnós which means "naked".
According to the myths of the cult Lathander was challenged by three powerful spirits: one was a spirit of contests, another was a spirit of rivalry, and the last was a spirit of victory. The youthful deity was known for his arrogance, but also his cunning so accepted the challenge. They engaged in various competitions, with the spirits attempting to trick him at every turn. However his cunning and creativity allowed him to see through their tricks, and he eventually won. All who participated offered something as a bet. Lathander promised them portions of his divinity should he lose, and they promised to teach him their secrets should he win. This is how Lathander became the patron god of the games, and the deity of athletics, vitality, youth, and self-perfection.
This roughly mirrors what scholars believe happened. There are a number of speculative origins for Lathander, but the most popular is that he may have been an ancient Turmani deity of the dawn, renewal, creativity, and birth. He was likely seen as a patron deity of children, particularly a protector of children, but also a symbol of new beginnings. ("Each child holds within them the spark of creativity, and each birth is a sign of renewal just as the dawn pushes back the dark to renew the day.")
After the fall of the Imaskari Empire in –2488 DR the Turmani were displaced by the Mulan, and were forced to migrate west along the southern coast of the Sea of Fallen Stars. Today, the Turmani primarily make up the bulk of the Turmish population but can also be found as a minority group in Mulhorand, Unther, Chessenta, and Chondath. During their migration their deities intermixed with deities brought over by the Imaskari slaves, which largely wiped out their pantheon. One of the exceptions may be Lathander.
Lathander is believed to have been challenged by three quasi-deities. (These would correlate to the Greek spirits Agon the spirit of contest, who possessed the altar at the Olympic Games, Zelos the spirit of rivalry and envy, and finally Nike (or Nicé) the spirit of victory in both battle and peaceful competition.) They attempted to defeat him in an effort to take his divinity and become full deities themselves. They failed and he absorbed them instead.
This in turn led to him gaining the portfolios of athletics, vitality, youth, and self-perfection. As one might expect those who take Lathander as their patron are athletes, those that aspire to be athletes, or those who have a strong devotion to the games and competitions. He is praised publicly before every game and competition, as people ask him to bless the competition, punish those who cheat, grant strength to the worthy, etc.
It's difficult to overstate how influential the cult is in Chessenta. No games or competitions can even be called without the blessing of the priests of Lathander. One of the major ways a noble or anyone of worth gains prestige in Chessenta is by sponsoring athletes in the games, and by "sponsoring" I mean paying money to the cult of Lathander. Prospective athletes are constantly seeking a patron, and the most successful athletes are like modern day pop stars. People throw themselves at you, you're able to get away with minor crimes with a slap on the wrist, and you have tons and tons of groupies who all want to worship you. They want you at parades and festivals. The wealthy and politically ambitious want to be seen with you.
However, the cult doesn't just make money off of the patronage of their athletes. Gambling on the games is encouraged and run by the cult as well. On top of that you have priests willing to accept offerings made to Lathander on behalf of your favorite athlete. Are you gambling? Then you'd best make an offering to Lathander and pray for your chosen athlete to increase your odds of winning!
Despite its influence and wealth, the cult is small. As previously mentioned it only accepts men as members. It's priesthood is all male as are all the athletes. Though Lathander receives quite a bit of praise when it comes time for competition and games, those who take him as their patron deity are usually athletes.
What really makes it different from other cults that you might see in the Realms is that it's somewhat like a mystery religion. It has many secret rites, rituals, and practices that are taught to athletes who hope to gain an edge and an advantage in the games.
Ironically, it's for this reason that the other cults of Lathander view the cult in Chessenta as heretical. Many of the secret practices that leak out really horrify the non-Chessentan cultists of Lathander. Not particularly because they're evil or anything, but mostly for the squick factor. They are also deemed heretical for their hero worship, which is actually quite common in Chessenta, but most obvious in the worship of Lathander. Great deceased heroic athletes are commonly called upon by living athletes to intercede on their behalf and assist them in earning Lathander's favor.
The western and northern cults of Lathander regularly send missionaries to Chessenta in an attempt to sway the folk of Chessenta from their heretical ways (as well as to work against the cult of Lathander there), though they have never had any serious success. When the Amaunator heresy appeared and started to sweep the western and northern cults, it had no impact on the cult in Chessenta. This remains true in my Realms even after the Spellplague.
Obviously, none of this is canon. However, I offer it up as something that might be useful in a home campaign. |
 |
|
|
MrHedgehog
Senior Scribe
  
688 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 20:06:56
|
quote: Originally posted by Wooly Rupert
No, I'm saying that complaining about gender exclusion and asking for more of it seems a bit odd. If something is bad, why do you want more of it?
It's also very ironic, because the usual complaint about sexism in fantasy is about how women are portrayed.
I'm sure if we quantified the representation of males and females there would be more males (as I posted about the number of greater deities who are male versus female) All the female only groups are noted exactly because it comes off as unusual (witches of Rashemen, drow matriarchy, etc.) while male dominated groups are portrayed as being the norm regardless of Ed's personal beliefs.
-The Princes of Shade (all male. In addition to Hadrhune and Telamont being male) Most of the other cunning villains are like this. Women are usually portrayed as emotionally unstable as the motivator for their evil. Envious, jealous, beautiful or hideously ugly,... -The Zulkirs of Thay were primarily male and the female Zulkirs were in feminine seeming forms of magic (Abjuration, Illusion, and Divination)
-Female deities are primarily in traditionally female areas (Chauntea = agriculture, Sune = beauty, Selune = unstable moody moon goddess....) So there's an all female order dedicated to flowers who worship Chauntea? I see how oppressive that must be to the original poster *eyes roll* The evil female deities are also given typical female roles Loviatar = Dominatrix, Shar = jealous bitter, Talona = jealous bitter, Beshaba = jealous bitter, Umberlee= jealous bitter, Lolth = jealous + bitter,...as the driving force for their existence and their evil. They are all bitter and angry and less important than their male counterparts. Male deities and characters are given more diverse characteristics that aren't as stereotypical in general.
|
 |
|
|
Aryalómë
Senior Scribe
  
USA
666 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 21:37:05
|
quote: Originally posted by Aldrick
quote: Originally posted by Markustay
Once you create any law/ruling that has to protect a specific group, you are then singling it out, which is the worst kind of prejudice.
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
@Markustay; Affirmative Action is extremely prejudiced against people of European background mostly; especially European descended men.
#Privilege

-------------
I'm going to pretend the above exchange didn't happen, and instead focus on answering your question. I have no idea if this is what you're talking about or not, and it certainly isn't canon. However, in my Realms the primary cult of Lathander in Chessenta is male only. They only accept male clergy and male members. Females can offer tribute to Lathander, but they can't be members of the cult.
Lathander is regarded as the deity of athletics, vitality, youth, and self-perfection in Chessenta. One of the things I wanted to do with Lathander in Chessenta - especially after the Amaunator heresy - was to differentiate his cult worship from the Heartlands and the North.
The male only part is a result of influence from the Mulan culture, tradition, and a huge admiration for the male body. Lathander is seen as the idealized form of male beauty. As characterized by Aristophanes a playwright of ancient Athens, the idealized male body was: "a gleaming chest, bright skin, broad shoulders, tiny tongue, strong buttocks, and a little prick." Statues of Lathander, which can be found pretty much in every city in Chessenta, reflect these preferences.
Chessenta is heavily inspired by ancient Greek culture, and I attempted to infuse it with a number of different elements from that culture. Canonically, athletics, wrestling in particular, is very important and popular culturally. The wrestling is done in the nude as it was done in ancient Greece. As the link points out the word Gymnasium comes from the Ancient Greek term gymnós which means "naked".
According to the myths of the cult Lathander was challenged by three powerful spirits: one was a spirit of contests, another was a spirit of rivalry, and the last was a spirit of victory. The youthful deity was known for his arrogance, but also his cunning so accepted the challenge. They engaged in various competitions, with the spirits attempting to trick him at every turn. However his cunning and creativity allowed him to see through their tricks, and he eventually won. All who participated offered something as a bet. Lathander promised them portions of his divinity should he lose, and they promised to teach him their secrets should he win. This is how Lathander became the patron god of the games, and the deity of athletics, vitality, youth, and self-perfection.
This roughly mirrors what scholars believe happened. There are a number of speculative origins for Lathander, but the most popular is that he may have been an ancient Turmani deity of the dawn, renewal, creativity, and birth. He was likely seen as a patron deity of children, particularly a protector of children, but also a symbol of new beginnings. ("Each child holds within them the spark of creativity, and each birth is a sign of renewal just as the dawn pushes back the dark to renew the day.")
After the fall of the Imaskari Empire in –2488 DR the Turmani were displaced by the Mulan, and were forced to migrate west along the southern coast of the Sea of Fallen Stars. Today, the Turmani primarily make up the bulk of the Turmish population but can also be found as a minority group in Mulhorand, Unther, Chessenta, and Chondath. During their migration their deities intermixed with deities brought over by the Imaskari slaves, which largely wiped out their pantheon. One of the exceptions may be Lathander.
Lathander is believed to have been challenged by three quasi-deities. (These would correlate to the Greek spirits Agon the spirit of contest, who possessed the altar at the Olympic Games, Zelos the spirit of rivalry and envy, and finally Nike (or Nicé) the spirit of victory in both battle and peaceful competition.) They attempted to defeat him in an effort to take his divinity and become full deities themselves. They failed and he absorbed them instead.
This in turn led to him gaining the portfolios of athletics, vitality, youth, and self-perfection. As one might expect those who take Lathander as their patron are athletes, those that aspire to be athletes, or those who have a strong devotion to the games and competitions. He is praised publicly before every game and competition, as people ask him to bless the competition, punish those who cheat, grant strength to the worthy, etc.
It's difficult to overstate how influential the cult is in Chessenta. No games or competitions can even be called without the blessing of the priests of Lathander. One of the major ways a noble or anyone of worth gains prestige in Chessenta is by sponsoring athletes in the games, and by "sponsoring" I mean paying money to the cult of Lathander. Prospective athletes are constantly seeking a patron, and the most successful athletes are like modern day pop stars. People throw themselves at you, you're able to get away with minor crimes with a slap on the wrist, and you have tons and tons of groupies who all want to worship you. They want you at parades and festivals. The wealthy and politically ambitious want to be seen with you.
However, the cult doesn't just make money off of the patronage of their athletes. Gambling on the games is encouraged and run by the cult as well. On top of that you have priests willing to accept offerings made to Lathander on behalf of your favorite athlete. Are you gambling? Then you'd best make an offering to Lathander and pray for your chosen athlete to increase your odds of winning!
Despite its influence and wealth, the cult is small. As previously mentioned it only accepts men as members. It's priesthood is all male as are all the athletes. Though Lathander receives quite a bit of praise when it comes time for competition and games, those who take him as their patron deity are usually athletes.
What really makes it different from other cults that you might see in the Realms is that it's somewhat like a mystery religion. It has many secret rites, rituals, and practices that are taught to athletes who hope to gain an edge and an advantage in the games.
Ironically, it's for this reason that the other cults of Lathander view the cult in Chessenta as heretical. Many of the secret practices that leak out really horrify the non-Chessentan cultists of Lathander. Not particularly because they're evil or anything, but mostly for the squick factor. They are also deemed heretical for their hero worship, which is actually quite common in Chessenta, but most obvious in the worship of Lathander. Great deceased heroic athletes are commonly called upon by living athletes to intercede on their behalf and assist them in earning Lathander's favor.
The western and northern cults of Lathander regularly send missionaries to Chessenta in an attempt to sway the folk of Chessenta from their heretical ways (as well as to work against the cult of Lathander there), though they have never had any serious success. When the Amaunator heresy appeared and started to sweep the western and northern cults, it had no impact on the cult in Chessenta. This remains true in my Realms even after the Spellplague.
Obviously, none of this is canon. However, I offer it up as something that might be useful in a home campaign.
Your Realms does not equal canon Realms, so your argument and wall of text mean nothing and even after reading it do no
quote: I'm sure if we quantified the representation of males and females there would be more males (as I posted about the number of greater deities who are male versus female) All the female only groups are noted exactly because it comes off as unusual (witches of Rashemen, drow matriarchy, etc.) while male dominated groups are portrayed as being the norm regardless of Ed's personal beliefs.
-The Princes of Shade (all male. In addition to Hadrhune and Telamont being male) Most of the other cunning villains are like this. Women are usually portrayed as emotionally unstable as the motivator for their evil. Envious, jealous, beautiful or hideously ugly,... -The Zulkirs of Thay were primarily male and the female Zulkirs were in feminine seeming forms of magic (Abjuration, Illusion, and Divination)
-Female deities are primarily in traditionally female areas (Chauntea = agriculture, Sune = beauty, Selune = unstable moody moon goddess....) So there's an all female order dedicated to flowers who worship Chauntea? I see how oppressive that must be to the original poster *eyes roll* The evil female deities are also given typical female roles Loviatar = Dominatrix, Shar = jealous bitter, Talona = jealous bitter, Beshaba = jealous bitter, Umberlee= jealous bitter, Lolth = jealous + bitter,...as the driving force for their existence and their evil. They are all bitter and angry and less important than their male counterparts. Male deities and characters are given more diverse characteristics that aren't as stereotypical in general.
That's a terrible and poor summary of the female goddesses of the Realms and does them no justice.
I'm sorry, but Lolth has always, in the past editions, especially so, been talked so much more than Corellon Larethian. Corellon is actually much more mysterious than Lolth is because Lolth, like her matriarchy, have been run into the ground by several authors and the community as a whole.
quote: Originally posted by Wooly Rupert
No, I'm saying that complaining about gender exclusion and asking for more of it seems a bit odd. If something is bad, why do you want more of it?
It's also very ironic, because the usual complaint about sexism in fantasy is about how women are portrayed.
Just as a sisterhood creates bonds between its members, so too could a brotherhood. No one needs to be sexist in order to have an organization dedicated or devoted to one gender.
One has to be completely blind to not see a problem here. |
Edited by - Aryalómë on 14 May 2013 21:40:33 |
 |
|
|
TheHermit
Seeker

USA
60 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 23:09:00
|
quote: Originally posted by Aryal�m� One has to be completely blind to not see a problem here.
I concur. |
- "Glitz & Klax's Potions & Elixirs"/"The Sandmen", Inside Ravens Bluff, The Living City; 1990; TSR, Inc. - "The Far Guardians' Traveler's Mission", Port of Ravens Bluff; 1991, TSR, Inc. - "Signs Painted", Polyhedron #70; April, 1992; TSR, Inc. - Communications Director, Coliseum of Comics, Orlando, FL - http://coliseumofcomics.com/ |
 |
|
|
Wooly Rupert
Master of Mischief

    
USA
36974 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 23:18:49
|
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
Just as a sisterhood creates bonds between its members, so too could a brotherhood.
Ah, so it's not possible to have two people of different genders share feelings of unity, camaraderie, purpose, and/or dedication to a greater cause/group. Somehow I'd never learned that. 
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
No one needs to be sexist in order to have an organization dedicated or devoted to one gender.
When membership is allowed or disallowed solely by gender, that's sexist. In fact, here's a definition from dictionary.com:
discrimination on the basis of sex, esp the oppression of women by men
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
One has to be completely blind to not see a problem here.
I'll agree. I'm very much seeing a problem here. But I'm fairly certain that the problem I'm looking at is not the one you're referring to. |
Candlekeep Forums Moderator
Candlekeep - The Library of Forgotten Realms Lore http://www.candlekeep.com -- Candlekeep Forum Code of Conduct
I am the Giant Space Hamster of Ill Omen!  |
 |
|
|
MrHedgehog
Senior Scribe
  
688 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 23:31:31
|
Aldrick put a great deal of effort into that "wall of text". It is more interesting to read his unique writings than here people whine about which page what was said in which published canon.
My rendition of the goddesses is true and accurate, sorry that you can't see the obvious conclusions? Lolth is talked about more because people are obsessed with dark elves. Correlon is certainly more important, and powerful than Lolth. Writing about him just isn't as interesting, and when would it come up, really? He's good so his worshipers would generally not be foes to protagonists of stories. It follows the same logic as good creatures existing just as much as evil ones they just aren't talked about because Dungeon and Dragons is a fighting game, not a friend making game. Why describe clergy of Correlon when they would not be enemies to the PCs? |
 |
|
|
Kentinal
Great Reader
    
4703 Posts |
Posted - 14 May 2013 : 23:52:50
|
*Rolls WIS check*
Oh so much to say. The Drow not to be discussed, Lolth used to have male Clerics.
Eilistraee as far as Ed is concerned permits male Clerics.
Real world myths have many female only creatures, Sirens, Nymphs, Marmaids.
Real world also had Knighthood that was male only.
TSR kept much of real world myth including limits on stats for females, it evolved a little to letting females be Knights. WotC with 3rd clearly reached further in using her in place of he to offer equality. They clearly did not see a need for a male only deity, and there are very few only female deities. Amazons might be one.
It also should be noted that the main focus of sales was and likely still is to males, though some effort has been made to make D&D and the Realms more female friendly.
If a person does not like the business choices of the company, your clear choice is to stop buying the product, with a secondary option of contacting the company requesting them to provide you the "balance" you expect. |
"Small beings can have small wisdom," the dragon said. "And small wise beings are better than small fools. Listen: Wisdom is caring for afterwards." "Caring for afterwards ...? Ker repeated this without understanding. "After action, afterwards," the dragon said. "Choose the afterwards first, then the action. Fools choose action first." "Judgement" copyright 2003 by Elizabeth Moon |
 |
|
|
Aldrick
Senior Scribe
  
909 Posts |
Posted - 15 May 2013 : 01:34:19
|
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
Your Realms does not equal canon Realms, so your argument and wall of text mean nothing and even after reading it do no
My apologies for attempting to offer you a solution to your dilemma. I am so very sorry that my feeble attempt to lessen the pain you endure failed. I can only imagine what you as a white cisgendered heterosexual male must endure on a daily basis, but know this - my heart breaks for you.
If I weren't a horrible dirty atheist I'd pray for you, but since I can't I can only hope that you'll find the courage to muster on with your crusade for equality. Fight on, brother. Fight on. |
 |
|
|
The Sage
Procrastinator Most High
    
Australia
31799 Posts |
Posted - 15 May 2013 : 03:16:26
|
I'm a little disturbed by the recent bout of exchanges between a number of scribes in this scroll.
I'd ask that of the folk involved, and in light of the fact that this is an all-ages forum, that should any of you feel the need to continue on this current track, you would do so through private messages instead.
Thank you. |
Candlekeep Forums Moderator
Candlekeep - The Library of Forgotten Realms Lore http://www.candlekeep.com -- Candlekeep Forum Code of Conduct
Scribe for the Candlekeep Compendium -- Volume IX now available (Oct 2007)
"So Saith Ed" -- the collected Candlekeep replies of Ed Greenwood
Zhoth'ilam Folio -- The Electronic Misadventures of a Rambling Sage |
 |
|
|
MrHedgehog
Senior Scribe
  
688 Posts |
Posted - 15 May 2013 : 21:09:37
|
“Beshaba has a secret society of assassins dedicated to her name called the Black Fingers. It is comprised of male members of her clergy and evil thieves and fighters” page 43 of Faiths and Avatars
“The Plague Mother's Children is a guild of thugs active throughout Chondath and the Vilhon Reach...it has degenerated into an informal brotherhood of thieves and fighters” page 153 of Faiths and Avatars
|
 |
|
|
EytanBernstein
Forgotten Realms Designer
  
USA
704 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 19:17:44
|
My first thought, reading this scroll, was definitely Lathander. But as a whole, the Realms is an extremely polytheistic society, not truly based on our world. And hence, while there may be degrees of gender exclusion in some places, the Realms, while having a somewhat medieval feel in places, is not actually medieval Europe.
Traditionally, all-female religious organizations in the real world have formed because women weren't allowed to be members of the dominant religions of their regions. Since this is not the case in the Realms, any male or female only sects are simply a case by case basis. The Realms has just about everything - religions that worship slime, religions that worship love, religions that worship war. So there are no doubt male-centric and female-centric religions, but these are the exception, not the rule.
All that said, I really doubt the need for such things. With the VAST majority of Realms faiths treating men and women equally, why is there a need for gender-specific sects? If there is a handful of female-only sects, that's likely because women are underrepresented in general in gaming, so throwing them to options is an attempt at diversity (which may or may not be successful).
Nevertheless, it's your game, so you can put whatever you want in it. |
http://eytanbernstein.com - the official website of Eytan Bernstein |
 |
|
|
Jeremy Grenemyer
Great Reader
    
USA
2717 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 20:17:28
|
quote: Originally posted by Aryalómë
I got extremely annoyed by this. There were several deities for women, but none for men. Why is D&D so sexist like this?
It doesn't follow that because there's a preponderance of one over the other that sexism exists.
Also, the Realms are fantasy, not reality. If you're interested in seeing more male-dominated religious groups or societies in the Realms, reach out to WotC and ask for it.
The more variety in the Realms the better, IMO.
quote: Originally posted by The Sage
I'm a little disturbed by the recent bout of exchanges between a number of scribes in this scroll.
I hope by "scribes" you mean to include your fellow moderator. Take it from a guy who knows: that was a textbook perfect example of trolling on Wooly's part. |
Look for me and my content at EN World (user name: sanishiver). |
 |
|
|
Diffan
Great Reader
    
USA
4491 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 20:54:11
|
| You know what I'd like to see in the Realms, an Organization specific to the proliferation of Humanity. Two outside elements quickly jump to mind: Cerberus from Mass Effect and the Imperium of Man from Warhammer 40K. In a setting that has dozens of sentient beings it sort of seems like there would be some council or gathering of people with varying heritage that put aside their own bigoted animosity for one another to instead focus on the real threats such as Dwarves, Elves, Halflings, etc. |
Diffan's NPG Generator: FR NPC Generator
E6 Options: Epic 6 Campaign |
 |
|
|
Markustay
Realms Explorer extraordinaire
    
USA
15724 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 20:54:12
|
quote: Originally posted by Jeremy Grenemyer
I hope by "scribes" you mean to include your fellow moderator. Take it from a guy who knows: that was a textbook perfect example of trolling on Wooly's part.
Uh-OH... LOL
The taboo subject. 
Anyhow, gender/race equality is always a touchy subject. The problem is, when you use rules/laws to correct it, you are singling out other groups (and opening them for exclusion because they are not a 'minority' - a word that has the strangest and most ambiguous definitions of late).
Just because no such groups have been detailed in Realms lore to date does not preclude their existence. Not only does that mean there could be hundreds of such groups we haven't heard of (yet), we could create a bunch in our HB Realms - we are free to 'interpret' the canon anyway we choose.
I understand there is a female-only Mercenary company based out of Ixinos. I am highly offended I cannot join (and use their locker-rooms). I say we go kick their butts. I would really like to get into a fight with them... preferably unarmed combat... with lots of jello involved.  |
"I have never in my life learned anything from any man who agreed with me" --- Dudley Field Malone
|
Edited by - Markustay on 17 May 2013 20:56:25 |
 |
|
|
Wooly Rupert
Master of Mischief

    
USA
36974 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 21:28:26
|
quote: Originally posted by Jeremy Grenemyer
quote: Originally posted by The Sage
I'm a little disturbed by the recent bout of exchanges between a number of scribes in this scroll.
I hope by "scribes" you mean to include your fellow moderator. Take it from a guy who knows: that was a textbook perfect example of trolling on Wooly's part.
What was trolling? I countered several of his points and then said I didn't see the problem he saw. And pointing out that I found his approach to the topic to be problematic -- promoting sexism while complaining about the same, being dismissive of people trying to help, etc -- is not trolling. Unless you're going to say that not happily agreeing with anything everyone says is trolling. |
Candlekeep Forums Moderator
Candlekeep - The Library of Forgotten Realms Lore http://www.candlekeep.com -- Candlekeep Forum Code of Conduct
I am the Giant Space Hamster of Ill Omen!  |
 |
|
|
MrHedgehog
Senior Scribe
  
688 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 21:47:28
|
quote: Originally posted by EytanBernstein
So there are no doubt male-centric and female-centric religions, but these are the exception, not the rule.
It seems like many of the evil deities have clergies dominated by one gender (Beshaba, Loviatar, Umberlee...) so i'm not sure I agree with that entirely. Although they are evil so perhaps that is why, and you didn't write that source material. Maybe it would have been different if you had? But your post is overall quite true!
I think its funny that Wooly is being accused of "trolling". You disagree with him so much that he must not be serious?
In regards to racist groups focused on humankind in my own imagination the Church of Bane proliferates hatred against non-humans. In my own campaign I made it so Melvaunt, Zhentil Keep and Mulmaster all followed Hillsfar in ousting non-humans. |
 |
|
|
MrHedgehog
Senior Scribe
  
688 Posts |
Posted - 17 May 2013 : 21:58:09
|
Inspired by this thread I made up a brotherhood:
Clowder of the Three Mothers Alignment: Chaotic Neutral Membership: 16 (humans 12 Genasi 2 Tiefling 1 Aasimar 2 Half-Elf 1) Authority Figures: Nip (CG male Aasimar Bard 13) Important Characters: Anoa (CG male Aasimar Sorcerer 8), Shadow Claw (CN male Tiefling Rogue 9), Moolin (CN male Chultan Bard 9) and Felar'afil (CN male Half-Elf Cleric [Sharess] 10) Other characters: Bard 3 (2), Bard 4, Bard 5, Sorcerer 4, Rogue 3 (2), Rogue 5, Cleric 2, Cleric 3, and Cleric 4.
Associated Classes: Cleric, bard, and rogue. Associated Skills: Perform (Dance, Drama, Sing, String, Percussion), Craft (Painting), Diplomacy, Disguise and Bluff.
Requirements: Patron deity must be Sharess. For someone to join they must be accepted by the group after attending several ritual revelries. Upon being accepted they must stay with the group and contribute to the community. If after an unspecified, and inconsistent, amount of time they are deemed part of the brotherhood they are invited to have a private rebirth ceremony where they are reborn as a child of one of the three goddesses which results in the groups' transmutation into women for the night of the ceremony.
This Brotherhood is devoted to emulating the “Three Mothers”, as they call them, that being Sharess, Zandilar and Bastet. They believe Sharess' component deities are three separate entities. They do this by living lives of hedonism, art, and performance in their commune in Calimport. The group is mostly disorganized and trying to get them to do something is akin to “herding cats” but they move about Calimport performing at different festhalls, theaters, street corners and alleys. They are quite a shocking sight in strange garb covered in paint, costumes, or even fully nude. They live to create art, entertain and perform but will not charge or make money from their art. Instead they work as prostitutes and steal from those who can afford to be taken from.
Clandestinely the group also gathers gossip and news that is sent back to clergy of the Festhall of Eternal Delight. They also occasionally decide to free slaves, oppressed persons, or break into the homes of tyrants or even assassinate clergy of Loviatar, Shar and especially any cultists of Set. |
 |
|
Topic  |
|
|
|