Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply. To register, click here. Registration is FREE!
T O P I C R E V I E W
Wooly Rupert
Posted - 09 Jan 2019 : 16:19:25 It occurs to me that Ed has been posting Realmslore on the Twitter, and not everyone has the Twitter.
So I thought a single place where such lore could be collected would be a good thing.
Ed is a frequent poster there, adding all sorts of Stormtalons and Epic Fantasy stuff, but for the purposes of this thread, I'd like to keep it focused on his Realmslore.
(I'm also stickying this thread, to make it easier to find)
Elminster (left) and Mordenkainen (right) having snacks in @TheEdVerse 's living room, with Ed hiding inside a suit of armor. #dnd #forgottenrealms #Realmslore
#128214;: The Wizards Three (Dragon #185) #127912;: Dan Burr
@TheEdVerse this might seems a strange question but what is the topography of Waterdeep? Like what streets are actually hills you have to head up? Does the sea ward sit ON the coast or above it? Etc.
Thanks! @TheEdVerse
See the beautiful foldout Val Valusek color drawing included in the CITY SYSTEM boxed set (Fr Wiki, City System entry, "Full aerial-view poster map." near the bottom of the entry). Sea Ward rise from a beach outside the city walls as one heads east/landward.
questing gm
Posted - 19 Dec 2024 : 01:18:55On how do people react to friendly monsters
@TheEdVerse In the Realms, how do people react to friendly monsters like, for instance, the famous kobold bard Deekin who lived in Neverwinter? Is he an outlier or is Faerûnian society (in general) welcoming or open to the concept of "good" monsters joining civilization? @TheEdVerse
Tolerance varies from place to place and with individuals, but "everybody knows" there are "good" monsters. Of course, the first time Person X sees Monster Y, they're not necessarily sure they're looking at a "good" =safe to be near monster.
questing gm
Posted - 15 Dec 2024 : 09:35:34On Juniper's Companion to Venturesome Cookery
Announcing: The Forgotten Realms Wiki Presents Juniper's Companion to Venturesome Cookery, a #DungeonsandDragons saucebook of delectable dishes straight from the #ForgottenRealms, with #cooking tips, culinary spells and magic items, and #Realmslore, coming soon!
@TheEdVerse Question for a friend! What is the lifespan of a child of an elf and a tiefling? ln our flailing guesswork, my assumption would be that since a normal human decended tiefling lives a little longer than human, a half elf one might live to 190-200? @TheEdVerse
I agree with your guesswork. ;} Barring disease or violent early death, likely around 200 summers.
@TheEdVerse Ao is the creator of the multiverse, but I'm confused about his extent of power. is he also the god behind Kryn and Dark sun? It would help me to have a better perspective on multiverses this as I am working on something. @TheEdVerse
Ao's not the creator of the multiverse; that's propaganda. Ao was installed as Realms overgod by a greater being after the Realms existed; he answers to a greater being, as seen in the published lore. He's not a creator deity or a guardian for either Athas or Krynn.
Loving this response for specifically the "Ao uses propaganda to overblow his supposed own power level", and thus "the sages that know" may be talking out their hind ends.
questing gm
Posted - 16 Nov 2024 : 12:44:34On peoples of the Realms actually know the events of the Time of Troubles
@TheEdVerse , quick question, how much of the events of the Time of Troubles do the peoples of the Realms actually know? Thinking about sending my 5e players back in time to experience the Realms during the time covered by the Grey Box when I started playing. @TheEdVerse
They know a lot, but much of it is spun/slanted or falsehoods, thanks to various clergies spotlighting their gods and decrying others, and wild runaway rumors. However, sages trying to be dispassionate can piece together a very good overall picture.
questing gm
Posted - 14 Nov 2024 : 11:37:47On sonnets in the Faerûn
@TheEdVerse Hi, lm sorry this is a weird question but I wanted to ask about Faerûnian sonnets. In a game I’m playing that’s set in Faerûn, they mention Sonnets and I’m just wondering how they got there? Is that a Faerûnian version of Shakespeare? Are they structurally different? @TheEdVerse
Sonnets got to the Realms through the gates (that are now largely "forgotten," hence the name Forgotten Realms. So, yes, they're structurally the same. I think I've written thirty-some sonnets that have been published, down the years.
questing gm
Posted - 12 Nov 2024 : 23:46:49On Ao the god of Kyrnn and Athas
@TheEdVerse Ao is the creator of the multiverse, but I'm confused about his extent of power. is he also the god behind Kryn and Dark sun? It would help me to have a better perspective on multiverses this as I am working on something. @TheEdVerse
Ao's not the creator of the multiverse; that's propaganda. Ao was installed as Realms overgod by a greater being after the Realms existed; he answers to a greater being, as seen in the published lore. He's not a creator deity or a guardian for either Athas or Krynn.
questing gm
Posted - 12 Nov 2024 : 23:40:06On name of sentient mimic
@TheEdVerse Does the sentient Mimic have a name? My adventuring party named it Chester. What episode did you mention it? @TheEdVerse
It calls itself “Melorurrumm,” which other mimics understand (to mean “Big One” or “Mess Not With This One” or “Formidable”), as many mimics that can’t speak can hear and understand a lot of Common. When talking with humans, elves, etc. it uses overheard human names it believes will lead them to treat it as harmless or eccentric rather than something to be instantly attacked, so it often calls itself “Humbert” or “Quilberforce” or “Jannatha.”
questing gm
Posted - 12 Nov 2024 : 23:33:21On solars versus powerful mages
I don't know if others had come up with this before, but… I seem to recall that it was either someone else who definitely had a say on a fraction of matters happening in the Realms (perhaps with doubtful precision without access to those powerful mages and such), or the Grand Mage he himself (and that's you!), said something like "Among all the editions, the stats back in AD&D portray the inhabitants of the Realms to the most accurate extend."
That set me off digging into materials concerning AD&D, and indeed, some of the settings were so different from those can be widely seen today. I saw in Dragon issue #91 El's stats for 1E, and in the boxed set lots of other interesting lores. However, what has shocked me about AD&D are some exceedingly powerful monsters back then that seem nigh invincible, so powerful that almost any attempt I can think of to translate these beings into later-edition versions would seem inappropriate as that would undoubtedly lead to a shrink in their capabilities. On top of my head, I recall solars, whose stats in 1E and 2E are, in a word, overpowered. Though I believe that, in the Realms, no one (or nothing) rivals great mages like Elminster in might, but these beings seem to stand a good chance.
So my question is… getting rid of the divine aid accessible to some of the powerful mages, in terms of overall power, does a solar have a fighting chance against anyone of the most powerful mages in the Realms (yeah, I know they're good guys…)?
Sincerely thanks. @TheEdVerse
Certainly they have a chance. Solars are of course the D&D version of one tier of angels. I had no hand at all in designing them (they’re “outer planar,” not “Realms”), but the overpowered aspect is due to differing design philosophies among D&D game editions.
In early editions of the game, there were beings who were supposed to be “too powerful” for PCs to defeat; just “out of mortal league.” Later game editions shifted to: gods have stats so your PCs can kill them and take their places.
So some of my early monsters (and a lot of deities designed by many folks) are “gross” in power level. That was deliberate: DON’T mess with these beings through combat. Negotiate or die. Whereas later on it became: PCs can do anything.
Just as Gary’s original D&D was: your PC is this one class, the class has strengths and grave weaknesses, too, so for success you MUST band together in a party and co-operate. Successive editions have moved towards min/max your character can have it all. @dmarcanist
Have you ever collaborated in the creation of character classes? Could there be a class native to the Realms, in addition to the classic ones? @TheEdVerse
Sure. Look at old DRAGON Magazines for my incantatrix, smith, beastmaster, etc. classes (billed as NPC classes as there was a rule against adding PC classes to the game without going through the rules committee). Some of these were supposed to be unique to the Realms.
questing gm
Posted - 06 Nov 2024 : 09:25:42On the 'mess' in the Moonsea
It's all of the Pirate Isles, individually named. Jeff Grubb added the blue marker to the photocopy I sent, to make it clear these particular lines are coasts, so it becomes a blue blob when seen from afar.
questing gm
Posted - 06 Nov 2024 : 09:15:12On what a myconid would order in a bar
@TheEdVerse What kind of drinks would a myconid consume at a bar if they were inclined to do so? @TheEdVerse
"Ironwater" for choice (ground water percolated through iron-rich [orange] soil), and other mineral waters for variety. Tree saps for dessert.
Athreeren
Posted - 02 Nov 2024 : 16:02:51
quote:Originally posted by Delnyn
Jander Sunstar schooled Strahd on the finer points of being a vampire. Concluding Jander is an older vampire than Strahd is extremely reasonable.
It is said explicitly in the book:
"Seven hundred?" He clearly thought Jander was speaking in jest. "Ah—I see. You are counting your years as a living being." "Well, yes," Jander admitted, "but that's only two centuries. I've been a vampire for five hundred years." Strahd was silent. "I cannot even conceive of such a thing," he said at last. "I am barely past my first century. You make me feel like a child again. What a great deal I have to learn from you!"
Strahd is the First Vampire of Barovia
questing gm
Posted - 02 Nov 2024 : 15:20:19On intention to connect Mystara with the Forgotten Realms
@TheEdVerse I was looking over a copy of the old Principalities of Glantri gazateer earlier this year, and a peculiar idea sort of took up residence in the corners of my mind. Without putting it all out there, is there any chance that there was ever an intention or an idea of connecting Mystara and the Forgotten Realms in any sense through the Principalities? @TheEdVerse
Yes. Unofficially, so DMs could run a high-level "across the worlds" campaign (like the later Planescape or the Spelljammer novels that involved travel from TSR world to TSR world), but the product lines remained distinct legally.
Like the World Serpent Inn? Have one of the back rooms open up onto Mystara? Sure it isn't strictly mentioned that there's a portal there, but I've used it before as a connection. Between Mystara and Sigil and Mystara and Toril. @TheEdVerse
Indeed. :} There are many "backdoor" connections between worlds. Knowing and controlling them (and fighting those who do) was the original Forgotten Realms high-level campaign.
questing gm
Posted - 02 Nov 2024 : 15:14:45On githyanki lactation
@TheEdVerse I was not able to find this question on the previous replies, but wanted to ask, given that Githyanki are hatched, do they lactate and what of the taste ? @TheEdVerse
They do, the breast milk serving to nourish for rapid growth, building of muscle tissue, and healing of organs and sinews. I am told (no personal experience here) that the taste is akin to rich chicken broth.
questing gm
Posted - 02 Nov 2024 : 15:08:16On Elminster knowing current lingo
@TheEdVerse What was the world that the Gray orcs came out of like? was it similar to Toril except with orcs being the dominant species? or was it simply a world with only orcs? @TheEdVerse
It was a diverse world (as Toril is), but generally colder and rockier (many mountain chains, verdant life in ravines and long valleys between the rock spurs). The orcs there "outbred" other races/ So, akin to the orc hordes of Toril, they went elsewhere in search of more food (instead of going on being ready food for the many hungry dragons of that world). So the dragons were the dominant species, whereas the orcs were the most numerous.
questing gm
Posted - 27 Oct 2024 : 12:45:05On describing the position of the Endless Waste
@TheEdVerse How would you describe the position of the Endless Wastes on the entire continent of Faerûn? @TheEdVerse
Hi, Ginny!
It depends on the context (i.e. who’s describing). Most far-traveled wayfarers call it “the Bit Between” as it lies between “the known lands of Faerûn and the East (Kara-Tur). Some caravan merchants have been known to call it “a whole lot of nothing.”
I call it “the Open Country” or “the Unexplored Country” because it’s never been visited properly in published Realmslore and because it’s a huge expanse of rolling, hilly grasslands.
questing gm
Posted - 27 Oct 2024 : 12:36:07On the full version of Ever A Hero Be
can anyone who is left on the DnD Side of Twitter help me hunt down a full version of Ever A Hero Be from The Forgotten Realms?perhaps @TheEdVerse? @TheEdVerse
Sure!
Though the sun be hot and bright Every realm gets dark and cold by night Somewhere always knows need for more light To comfort and guide, and perils highlight And that glow comes from people like you and me
So we need the right folk, to stand proud and strong To walk the brighter road, be it hard and long To sort what is right from all fair-seeming wrong To swell hearts and minds with a better song And be a hero for you and for me
But deep in halls dark and haunted Even heroes bold, high-vaunted Twice and thrice, to end up daunted Think of loved ones deeply wanted And much safer places to be
So the life is hard and too often dark And every battle leaves its mark Yet the world sore needs their special spark Their lack is all too clear and stark So we all yearn a hero for to see
Wherefore if the chance should come to you To noble cause cleave right true And through all fell foes staunchly hew So we weaker sorts will look to you As you ever a hero be
Hero be Hero be May you ever a hero be!
(The last three lines are sung slow, loud, and emphatic/triumphal. Ever a Hero Be was a ballad penned by Thalloviir Vaundruth, Bard of Beregost, in 1344 DR.)
Delnyn
Posted - 26 Oct 2024 : 22:56:01 Jander Sunstar schooled Strahd on the finer points of being a vampire. Concluding Jander is an older vampire than Strahd is extremely reasonable.
The Sage
Posted - 24 Oct 2024 : 00:47:11 And besides… 4e’s The Shadowfell pretty much played fast and loose with time and temporalities when it came to the Dread Domains and their Darklords. I don’t think that’s really been tweaked all that much in the 5e RAVENLOFT material… so Strahd could, conceivably, be happening/happened ANY time and any when.
questing gm
Posted - 23 Oct 2024 : 02:07:03On Strahd as the first vampire
@TheEdVerse so I was doing a quick search and couldn't find a definitive answer. Is Strahd the first vampire ever? Or were the vampires created by Orcus before him? Ravenloft timeline is weird, because Strahd would be just a couple of centuries old and there are older vampires. @TheEdVerse
No, there were and are thousands of vampires who are older than Strahd. @halfwhitebigode
So they are indeed the creation of Orcus? @TheEdVerse
Orcus is a destroyer and tyrant, not a creator. Believe no Orcus propaganda. Vampires are older than Orcus, too.
@TheEdVerse Can chubby elves exist if they don't exercise/eat lots of pastries? @TheEdVerse
Of course. If they eat or imbibe or get subjected to anything that shifts their metabolic rate, they either get VERY "hyper" or they gain weight (depending on which way the metabolism gets shifted).
questing gm
Posted - 14 Oct 2024 : 04:13:09On Lords of Waterdeep wearing masks
@TheEdVerse Hello Ed!! I’ve been infatuated with the forgotten realms since forever, and I’ve just recently started reading the Elminster books. I’ve noticed that Farl doesn’t seem to have a description. Does he have one that you know of? I’d love to draw him, he’s my favorite!! @TheEdVerse
Farl was slim, wiry and strong, had very dark brown hair (looked nigh black), brown eyes, and tawny skin; he was Damaran. Thin-line moustache, close-cropped razor-edged "daggerboard" sideburns, and back-of-neck length hair. Handsome, lithe. Fast grin, likeable.
questing gm
Posted - 12 Oct 2024 : 09:46:47On other families joining the cult of Asmodeus
Good day to Saer @TheEdVerse (Steven E Schend appears to have vanished!).
The Cassalanters reinvigorated Asmodeus worship in the early 1490’s. Are there any other families who featured prominently in their new cult? @TheEdVerse
Not “prominently,” no. Behind closed doors and undercover, YES, but…they were ambitious wannabe-noble rising wealthy merchant families, like the Dzunborns and Ilindravvars of Sea Ward and the Jarandurs, Maendreths, and Sourntrils of North Ward.
Among the ranks of Waterdeep’s nobles, aside from the Cassalanters, worshippers tended to be wastrel “black sheep” uncles and aunts, the disaffected and usually unwed and debauched elder brothers and sisters not in line to head their house.
Such individuals included Gastorn Brokengulf (NE hm R3); Szelruena Agundar (CE hf Sor6); Ilmur Artemel (CE hm F4), and Naranta Sultlue (CE hf R7).
questing gm
Posted - 12 Oct 2024 : 09:40:36On big tobacco growing regions in Faerun
@TheEdVerse Hail and well met! I was very much a pipe tobacco nerd in college, knowing far too much about various varieties and blends. I know tobacco originates across the sea, but are there any big tobacco growing regions in Faerun? I can't imagine wizards without a pipe! @TheEdVerse
“Big” is a relative term, but there are several small pipeweed growing areas in Faerûn. You need sandy (or gravel) soil and a temperate climate. Here are a few: coastal southern Ulgarth, Durpar on the west bank of the Heldar, the shores of the Great Sea in Konigheim (the Utter East), near the northern headwaters of the River of Spears in Mulhorand (north of Klondor), just south of the Firward Mountains in Ashanath, and just west of the Tsurlar Forest in the Vast (east of the Stormcrest Trail).
There are many more small local “pockets” of pipeweed growing, as it’s now (in 1500 DR) a companion plant grown to protect some food crops. @McCarthy_JT
Just to be clear, is Toril pipe weed more like tobacco or more like marijuana? @TheEdVerse
Pipeweed grown on Toril is the equivalent of tobacco. Calming and SLIGHTLY deadens nausea and pain. NO hallucinogenic effects unless things have been added to it. So, tobacco, not marijuana. @DecryptedTech
Didn't Elminster have a patch he grew near him home in Shadowdale? @TheEdVerse
It wasn't Elminster's patch; the local old lady who grew it just let him harvest some, in return for occasional cantrips cast (mending, usually) when she needed them. But yes, there were several private patches around Shadowdale. @FarrarN57854
Ahhh, Konigheim, how many times did I lie & say I went there & got it there, instead of discussing my supply chain. @TheEdVerse
Heh. Pipeweed is tobacco, not marijuana. ;} @FarrarN57854
Right, but historically, tobacco sources were a high conflict trade market, close to the big police corruption scandals, which would turn into poisoning farms -so confidential sources laws often started with tobacco industry. @TheEdVerse
Pipeweed in the Realms isn't as addictive as real-world tobacco, and many rural folk smoke local leaves and shoots (not pipeweed), so the markets are different in volume and nature (not illicit in the Realms, not "sin" taxed) than in our historical real world. - Edited on 14/10/24 to add new tweets