| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Cronje |
Posted - 05 May 2011 : 09:36:22
I was browsing the first edition Forgotten Realms Campaign Set and noticed that, in the Dove Falconhand entry, she was a worshiper of Mielikki. Aside from this source, is there any other reference to her worshiping Mielikki? Does she worship both Mielikki and Mystra? Did she change deities at some point? |
| 12 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| Dennis |
Posted - 18 May 2011 : 00:27:42
Ed just confirmed that everything we said is correct. |
| Barastir |
Posted - 17 May 2011 : 12:26:43
Hey gal and guys,
Ed has replied our question in his scrolls, let's go check it out: http://forum.candlekeep.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=14621&whichpage=36 |
| Barastir |
Posted - 12 May 2011 : 15:25:45
Hi, gal and guys! I've sent our questions to Ed's scroll, let's see what he or THO can say about it! |
| Alystra Illianniis |
Posted - 11 May 2011 : 04:28:09
I was going to point that out, too, but BEAST beat me to it. Nice catch. Also, although she is a Chosen, as BEAST pointed out, she prefers melee to magic. This probably colors her duties to Mystra to some extent, and might also be why she worships Mielikki. |
| BEAST |
Posted - 10 May 2011 : 23:03:51
quote:
Originally posted by Cronje
I was browsing the first edition Forgotten Realms Campaign Set and noticed that, in the Dove Falconhand entry, she was a worshiper of Mielikki. Aside from this source, is there any other reference to her worshiping Mielikki? Does she worship both Mielikki and Mystra? Did she change deities at some point?
The 2E lorebook Code of the Harpers says that she was secretly one of Mystra's Chosen. Could she have publicly worshipped Mielikki, and privately Mystra?
She was known to have preferred melee to magic, so maybe it was a little about keeping up appearances?
quote:
Originally posted by Thauramarth
Edit: Oh, and Dove played a supporting role in Exile, the second book in the Dark Elf trilogy.
Correction: She appeared in the third book, Sojourn. That was the book in which Drizzt became a surface-dweller. He was still living in the Underdark in the second. |
| Barastir |
Posted - 09 May 2011 : 14:06:53
quote:
Originally posted by DennisOn the matter about Dove worshiping Mielikki, well, you did point out the obvious thing that makes such "dual faith" not surprising: Dove is a ranger, and Mielikki is The Supreme Ranger.
Most of the deities indicated on the old box were based on alignment and class. There is some sort of deities' guide in the 1e FR material, I just don't remember if it was in the original box or in some accessory (like "Waterdeep and the North").
The question is: was that published according to Ed's idea, or revised by him? Maybe that's a question for the Chamber os Sages... |
| Dennis |
Posted - 07 May 2011 : 03:30:08
quote:
Originally posted by Thauramarth
quote:
Originally posted by Cronje
Aye, that much I knew from the Forgotten Realms Wiki, but I know that's not a complete reference by a long shot. The Seven Sisters fascinate me, so I read those articles a lot. Does Dove appear in any of the novels? If I recall correctly, she played a minor role in one of the novels with Sharantyr in it (it was a long while ago that I read them, so I might be getting her confused with a different Sister). Maybe one of the novels can shed some light?
Edit: Just noticed that, on the same page in the FRCS, it says that Elminster has no patron deity, so Dove worshiping Mielikki might not be accurate, despite that other reference. Still would like to see what other people say, though.
Not speaking for Ed, of course, but based on his (and THO's) writings in his thread, and in general, religious worship in the Realms is very much non-exclusive. Even priests can (and do) pay homage to deities other than their patron on a regular basis.
Correct. Provided, of course, that the deities being worshiped are not enemies. One can't expect a priestess to worship both Shar and Selune at the same time.
On the matter about Dove worshiping Mielikki, well, you did point out the obvious thing that makes such "dual faith" not surprising: Dove is a ranger, and Mielikki is The Supreme Ranger. |
| Lord Karsus |
Posted - 05 May 2011 : 18:07:26
-A lot of "fuzziness" in that regard has to do with the development of the setting. Many of the concepts, people, places, and so on, weren't fully developed to the degree that we recognize them now- or even developed at all- at the time the setting was first released. |
| Thauramarth |
Posted - 05 May 2011 : 11:28:29
quote:
Originally posted by Cronje
Aye, that much I knew from the Forgotten Realms Wiki, but I know that's not a complete reference by a long shot. The Seven Sisters fascinate me, so I read those articles a lot. Does Dove appear in any of the novels? If I recall correctly, she played a minor role in one of the novels with Sharantyr in it (it was a long while ago that I read them, so I might be getting her confused with a different Sister). Maybe one of the novels can shed some light?
Edit: Just noticed that, on the same page in the FRCS, it says that Elminster has no patron deity, so Dove worshiping Mielikki might not be accurate, despite that other reference. Still would like to see what other people say, though.
Not speaking for Ed, of course, but based on his (and THO's) writings in his thread, and in general, religious worship in the Realms is very much non-exclusive. Even priests can (and do) pay homage to deities other than their patron on a regular basis. The precise reference escapes me, but THO once mentioned the case of a priestess of Bane who made regular devotions to Ilmater (I'm sure Sage or someone else can point to the exact page) . The patron deities listed in the NPC descriptions would be the deities the NPC turns to mostly, or which are closest to his or her beliefs, but this does not mean that they pay homage and devotion to other deities. This approach to religious worship is probably one of the least developed aspects of published FR Lore.
From what I remember, Dove was listed in the original Grey Box (1987, way before the concept of the Chosen became part of published realms material) as worshipping Mielikki. As she is a ranger, this should not be a surprise. As a ranger, in 1E and 2E, she had access to divine magic. According to The Seven Sisters, she prays to Mystra for renewal of her spells. In spite of this, I think it is logical for her to pay homage to Mielikki, given that Dove is, first and foremost, a ranger, and Mielikki is the patron of rangers (much like any mage, regardless of alignment, would pay homage to Mystra in one way or the other). She would not be a priestess, or even a servant of Mielikki (like Qilué is to Eilistraee), but she could be a devotee.
Edit: Oh, and Dove played a supporting role in Exile, the second book in the Dark Elf trilogy. |
| Cronje |
Posted - 05 May 2011 : 10:12:12
Aye, that much I knew from the Forgotten Realms Wiki, but I know that's not a complete reference by a long shot. The Seven Sisters fascinate me, so I read those articles a lot. Does Dove appear in any of the novels? If I recall correctly, she played a minor role in one of the novels with Sharantyr in it (it was a long while ago that I read them, so I might be getting her confused with a different Sister). Maybe one of the novels can shed some light?
Edit: Just noticed that, on the same page in the FRCS, it says that Elminster has no patron deity, so Dove worshiping Mielikki might not be accurate, despite that other reference. Still would like to see what other people say, though. |
| _Jarlaxle_ |
Posted - 05 May 2011 : 10:04:29
Thats not uncommon. Qilué for example worshipped Mystra and Eilistraee and was a choosen of both |
| Tyranthraxus |
Posted - 05 May 2011 : 09:44:34
Hall of Heroes also states she's a follower of Mielikki. This may be a question for Ed. |
|
|
