| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Chronthalas |
Posted - 29 Nov 2014 : 02:19:32
One thing that really both surprised me and disappointed me was how the death of Dove Falconhand and her presence in Myth Drannor was handled in the book. She never got to met Storm, Elminster, Alustriel or Laeral while in Myth Drannor. Considering the strong bond between both the seven sisters and Elminster as fellow chosen of Mystra, none of them even felt her die. At least you would think that at the very end of the book, when Mystra visits the surving heroes in Storm's kitchen she would tell them the sad news, but no everyone is smiling and chuckling.
The whole ending felt extremly rushed. Does anyone know if Ed Greenwood has done any interviews or posted anything about what happened to several of the characters in the book?
|
| 14 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| Arcanus |
Posted - 03 Dec 2014 : 22:40:52
quote:
Originally posted by Tanthalas
I wouldn't call Mystra getting depowered a "wrong".
I wouldn't call it a "right" either.
It was just another plot element.
Maybe but the restoring of the majority realms to pre 4e would suggest that many fans saw 4e as wrong. I'm not turning this into a 4e bashing either, onwards and upwards  |
| Tanthalas |
Posted - 03 Dec 2014 : 19:18:45
I wouldn't call Mystra getting depowered a "wrong".
I wouldn't call it a "right" either.
It was just another plot element. |
| Arcanus |
Posted - 03 Dec 2014 : 00:46:46
quote:
Originally posted by Eilserus
I'd be curious to know IF Mystra can return to full power. A whole lot of magic blew up with the Spellplague. If magic is the foundation of her power, the Spellplague took a sledgehammer to the foundation of her house, maybe even a wrecking ball. I wouldn't be surprised if she is only an intermediate power at present.
I wouldn't think so. The weave is back and just being THE goddess of magic pretty much assures a greater god status. Mystra also saw off Shar at the end of the Herald, I doubt she would have been able to if she were a lesser power. |
| Eilserus |
Posted - 02 Dec 2014 : 23:48:18
I'd be curious to know IF Mystra can return to full power. A whole lot of magic blew up with the Spellplague. If magic is the foundation of her power, the Spellplague took a sledgehammer to the foundation of her house, maybe even a wrecking ball. I wouldn't be surprised if she is only an intermediate power at present. |
| Arcanus |
Posted - 02 Dec 2014 : 23:33:33
quote:
Originally posted by BenN
quote:
Originally posted by Arcanus
I thought it achieved its goal in righting some of the wrongs of 4e
What 'wrongs' in particular?
Returning Mystra to full power for one. |
| Richard Lee Byers |
Posted - 02 Dec 2014 : 14:10:37
Release dates CAN be changed, but it is a hassle and can cost the publisher money. In the case of the books in the Sundering series, where there was a plan in place to bring one out every two months, the publisher would have been that much more averse to not staying on schedule.
Which is not to say that I am seconding Chronthalas's opinion that The Herald reads like the writing was rushed. I'm not. But, C., that's the answer to the question about publishing that you posed. |
| BenN |
Posted - 02 Dec 2014 : 01:46:49
quote:
Originally posted by Arcanus
I thought it achieved its goal in righting some of the wrongs of 4e
What 'wrongs' in particular? |
| Arcanus |
Posted - 02 Dec 2014 : 00:04:01
Ed is a great guy but his writing style is not something everyone enjoys. I myself love his characters but think his use of them is sometimes somewhat predictable. Ed also likes to leave lots of plot hooks for gamers in his novels, that's great for RPG fans but can leave the novel only readers a little frustrated.
That being said, I thought that The Herald was an improvement on the previous couple of his books and aside from a few annoying things (like Dove dying meaninglessly), I thought it achieved its goal in righting some of the wrongs of 4e |
| Chronthalas |
Posted - 01 Dec 2014 : 16:35:31
Having characters whose fate are unknown in a novel is far from uncommon and it's really not my main issue with the tale. The complete lack of acknowledgement of Dove fighting and presumably dying in Myth Drannor while most of the other protagonists are present is much harder to swallow though.
For those of you that are involved in the publishing industry. When the release date is announced for a novel, is that date written in stone or can it be pushed back? The Herald is a fairly short book with only 19 chapters and as I wrote earlier to me it feels very rushed, akin to a computer game that is released too soon and needs multiple patches before it works properly. I'm just wondering if Greenwood worked under the pressure of a deadline that was to strict. |
| A Publishing Lackey |
Posted - 01 Dec 2014 : 15:19:14
Oh, don't think anyone who has worked with Ed would ever describe him as having a sloppy writing style.
Most of us in publishing are more in awe of how quickly he can work and how many distinct voices he can write in, to order. That and being a generous, nice guy has got him many, many projects down the years. Sloppy writers might get away with one or two bad projects, but they would hardly be able to maintain 50-year careers and sell well upwards of 70 million copies worldwide, as Ed has. (No, I'm not exaggerating.)
Ed may be many things, but "sloppy" isn't one of them.  |
| Tanthalas |
Posted - 30 Nov 2014 : 03:07:30
quote:
Originally posted by Blueblade
O
As the creator of the Realms, Ed writes his books like an unfolding tapestry, not tidy "we only concentrate on one plot, and it all gets wrapped up in the same book" yarns, and always has (one of the reasons he's had so many battles with editors over four decades and counting).
Well, that certainly sounds better than saying that he has a sloppy writing style.
It's possible that in the future Ed will do more stuff with Dove (I'm certain that he has plenty of ways to bring her back if he really wants to). But concerning The Herald, the way Dove was handled was one of the major criticisms I have of the book. |
| Blueblade |
Posted - 30 Nov 2014 : 01:49:41
Oh, I think you will get a reply.
Though what happened to Dove has been discussed, here and elsewhere, and Ed has said something to the effect of more will be revealed in future novels.
As the creator of the Realms, Ed writes his books like an unfolding tapestry, not tidy "we only concentrate on one plot, and it all gets wrapped up in the same book" yarns, and always has (one of the reasons he's had so many battles with editors over four decades and counting). There's something going on with Dove that hasn't been explained yet.
What? Your guess is as good as mine, but Ed has hinted that the precise words she spoke should be "weighed carefully."
BB |
| Chronthalas |
Posted - 29 Nov 2014 : 20:24:57
I actually sent Mr. Greenwood an email, though I doubt I'll get any reply. It's just such a major detail to omit, for me at least. |
| Delwa |
Posted - 29 Nov 2014 : 12:58:51
I know THO has answered several queries about the book in the "Questions for Ed Greenwood" thread. I'm not sure if your specific issue was addressed, though. I don't remember it, but that doesn't mean anything other than I'm rolling a "1" on my Intelligence check. |
