T O P I C R E V I E W |
Jamallo Kreen |
Posted - 07 Jul 2005 : 20:47:22 From the Forum "Questions for Ed Greenwood":
quote: Originally posted by The Hooded One
Well met again, fellow scribes. Reefy, rest assured that I shall treasure my friend and great dungeon master Ed, who herewith speaks on the matter of the language of drow:
Faraer, Zandilar, et al: I believe that the language spoken by the drow of today is rooted in the elf tongue spoken by the drow before they ‘went under,’ but all that survives from the elvish they spoke then (which of course has continued to be spoken by other elf races, and hence developed in a different direction, changing more rapidly in the last few centuries than it ever did in earlier times, thanks to all the intermingling of elves with other races, and words being needed for new concepts and things as elves encountered genuinely new customs, industries, and so on) is a smattering of vocabulary and the grammatical structure that underpins it all.
Which as Zandilar correctly points out, is the aspect of all non-Common tongues in Faerûn most neglected thus far. Most of us haven’t the time to delve into full linguistic development, particularly as most publishers would regard promoting such a thing (as anything but a web enhancement) to be financial suicide. What most DMs and Realms fiction writers are looking for is a handful of useful, cool-sounding words or phrases to give flavour to the speech of nonhumans (like the orc guards the PCs are creeping up on, the elf courtiers they’re eavesdropping on, or the dragon they overhear). In many cases, these will be used mixed in with Common, just as many English speakers of today lard their speech with individual words or even phrases from Spanish or French.
The reasons the drow tongue now shares so little vocabulary with surface elven speech is threefold: the Underdark is a very different environment than the Realms Above, so new names and terms were urgently needed, while a lot of words were no longer in daily use and started to fade; there was a deliberate political attempt to distance the drow from the Hated Ones who’d spurned them (other elves), just as there’s a recent real-world American mood of anger against France re. the political disagreements over Iraq, with moves to change “french fries” to “freedom fries” and so on; and Lolth / Lloth (and her priestesses, under her command) saw controlling the very speech of the drow as a sure means to complete dominance over other faiths (both the “former faiths” of the surface elves, and the various other faiths, such as those of Vhaeraun, Ghaunadar, and later Eilistraee, that the drow had been dabbling in).
(snip)
So saith Ed. Who’s answered Faraer’s question very well, I think, though of course debates on drow language and everything else drow will continue to rage for years, alongside creative work on drow speech. All of which proves that most of us have too much idle time, but we sure know how to choose a superior way to fill it! love to all, THO
A couple of years ago I read that Klingon speakers were in demand as staffers at mental hospitals because many patients now regard Klingon as their "native language." ("I'm not making this up, you know!")
Klingon has done remarkably well as a language. Is there a demand for Drow or Alzhedo or Chondathan dictionaries and grammars? Perhaps some of the more linguisticly talented among the scribes would consider undertaking such as an Act of Reverance...?
|
17 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
Arivia |
Posted - 02 Feb 2006 : 11:51:24 quote: Originally posted by Volo
Actually, it's the chief language of most of Faerun. Which is why I want to go about constructing it. Or expanding it, anyway. Although I'm not aware of any place where any part of it has been written down; it's simply translated into English in every text I've read.
Intriguingly enough, even Ed himself doesn't seem to have a dictionary for Chondathan---I've a printout of a reply of his to Kajehase about Chondathan words used on maps from sometime around the 9th of October last year tucked into the back of my copy of LEoF, and this was part of it:
quote: Ed I made much of this up on the spot, because the Chondathan written language in my notes consists of only a few fragments (so there isn't much more than what's here to reveal to you).
Dig up that reply for a few notes, I guess. |
Volo |
Posted - 02 Feb 2006 : 11:21:20 Actually, it's the chief language of most of Faerun. Which is why I want to go about constructing it. Or expanding it, anyway. Although I'm not aware of any place where any part of it has been written down; it's simply translated into English in every text I've read. |
Vangelor |
Posted - 02 Feb 2006 : 05:35:16 As well as the Dalelands, I believe. |
Jamallo Kreen |
Posted - 01 Feb 2006 : 21:48:25 quote: Originally posted by The Sage
quote: Originally posted by Jashan
Hrm. Not familiar with Chondath, although for some reason I'm thinking it's very far north. Is that a race or a region?
Chondath is a region and Chondathan is a human ethnic group. And it's located in the south... south of the Inner Sea and just south of Turmish across the Vilhon Reach.
Major references to Chondath occur in the FRCS 1e, 2e and 3e, Old Empires, Vilhon Reach, Sea of Fallen Stars.
Vilhon Reach can be downloaded for free at WotC here:- http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/dnd/downloads
Chondathan is one of the principal languages of the Western Heartlands, including Waterdeep and its environs. |
The Sage |
Posted - 01 Feb 2006 : 00:16:44 quote: Originally posted by Jashan
Hrm. Not familiar with Chondath, although for some reason I'm thinking it's very far north. Is that a race or a region?
Chondath is a region and Chondathan is a human ethnic group. And it's located in the south... south of the Inner Sea and just south of Turmish across the Vilhon Reach.
Major references to Chondath occur in the FRCS 1e, 2e and 3e, Old Empires, Vilhon Reach, Sea of Fallen Stars.
Vilhon Reach can be downloaded for free at WotC here:- http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/dnd/downloads
|
Jashan |
Posted - 31 Jan 2006 : 21:51:16 Hrm. Not familiar with Chondath, although for some reason I'm thinking it's very far north. Is that a race or a region?
As far as I'm aware, no one's ever attempted to do a human language (like Maztican or something) -- humans get no love :) It's always dwarves and elves. (Although no one's ever tried Halfling or Gnome, either, to my awareness).
BTW, regarding my Drow project, I've put up a little "collaboration messageboard" for it at http://www.jashan.net/sites/conlangs/etora/board/. |
Volo |
Posted - 31 Jan 2006 : 14:10:59 I, too, am a linguistics geek, and I've been considering how much fun I could have with designing a functional Chondathan language. (I know. I'm crazy.) |
Brian R. James |
Posted - 29 Jan 2006 : 16:46:18 Excellent research Jashan. Most impressive. |
Jashan |
Posted - 29 Jan 2006 : 08:05:00 Resurrecting an old, old thread...
I'm one of those linguistic types, and a while back (quite a while back), I decided I didn't care for the TSR/Wizard's version of the Drow language -- which is essentially "English with funny words." I made a purposefully complex and different version of Drow based off some of the Tolkein elvish materials, but disliked it and stopped work on it.
Recently after getting several requests for people to make it more useable, I've decided to do that.
I haven't done much with it yet other than sketch out some basic thoughts on the language itself (PDF format, here. Surprisingly (or perhaps not), Greenwood and I came up with a lot of common points independantly.
So, right now I'm looking for people who would be interested in this project, either just in receiving updates on it, or even participating. While some things I'm going to make up on my own, no real language thrives without input from interested listeners/speakers.
So... if anyone's interested, or has feedback in general (i.e. "X is terribly unrealistic" or "Y is absolutely fabulous!"), free free to share here or in my email (jashanaal.at.yahoo.dot.com)
Mod edit: Fixed the coding for the link, so it showed up correctly.  |
Jamallo Kreen |
Posted - 08 Jul 2005 : 01:33:09 quote: Originally posted by Vangelor
I was looking for something of this sort just recently, and found a document in which some hardworking soul had compiled published snippets of elven words and phrases from the Forgotten Realms corpus, in spreadsheet form.
Googling just now, I have located the page where I found this again. Here is a link:
http://hometown.aol.com/semberholme/language.htm
Apparantly a lot of this material originated with Steven Schend. Perhaps the good elvenfolk of Semberhome can be persuaded to share a copy of this scroll with Candlekeep? It seems a worthy resource.
That page leads to one with a terrific-looking Espruar font, apparently released c. 2002: http://hometown.aol.com/semberholme/espruar.htm. The older Espruar font I had wasn't nearly as sweet as this one. Blessings upon the heads of fontcrafters! Sami Pyörre, creator of the Everchanging Book of Names (http://ebon.pyorre.net/ -- not usable in Mac, alas!) supplies a link to a page dedicated to Ardalambion Of the Tongues of Arda, the invented world of J.R.R. Tolkien (http://www.uib.no/People/hnohf/), from which one may port to pages on several lanhuages, including Tolkien's elvish tongues. They may be of interest to those trying to construct a grammar of Faerûnian languages. Sami also provides a link to The Language Construction Kit (http://www.zompist.com/kit.html), which is of great worth to those constructing an artifical language. ==================================
|
Faraer |
Posted - 08 Jul 2005 : 00:27:22 There have been several abortive attempts to do this on the main Realms forums. It requires (a) a concerted effort by several people to assemble all the extant fragments of the given language, and (b) at least one person with linguistic expertise. It hasn't come together yet, but maybe some day!
The Grey Company link is ersatz Quenya with no relation to Realms languages except a few scattered words. The Semberholme link is Steven Schend's Cormanthyr language notes (I'd still be glad to see those in their original form, Steven!) mixed with other Realms bits and Grey Company pseudo-Quenya. |
Wooly Rupert |
Posted - 08 Jul 2005 : 00:17:59 I'm a geek, but not enough of a geek to want to learn a fictitious language.  |
Vangelor |
Posted - 08 Jul 2005 : 00:04:26 That last looks to me like information on Sindarin, one of Professor Tolkien's languages. Since these are so well documented, many roleplayers have gravitated toward them. I prefer to steer away when I can, in order to keep my vision of the Realms as distinct as possible form Middle Earth. After all, Tolkien would never have named even a green elf "Vangelor". 
--edit--
I looked a bit deeper, and there is a lot of Tolkienien elvish there, but also stuff that is more recent (references to the drow, who are a far cry from the Professor's Moriquendi) and of game-related origin. A good compilation for those who prefer to include, rather than exclude. Thanks. |
Kentinal |
Posted - 07 Jul 2005 : 23:58:06 Oh if I must
http://www.grey-company.org/Circle/language/grammar.htm Elven, I believe also includes Drow.
The others listed do not show up in search. |
Vangelor |
Posted - 07 Jul 2005 : 23:57:49 I was looking for something of this sort just recently, and found a document in which some hardworking soul had compiled published snippets of elven words and phrases from the Forgotten Realms corpus, in spreadsheet form.
Googling just now, I have located the page where I found this again. Here is a link:
http://hometown.aol.com/semberholme/language.htm
Apparantly a lot of this material originated with Steven Schend. Perhaps the good elvenfolk of Semberhome can be persuaded to share a copy of this scroll with Candlekeep? It seems a worthy resource.
|
Crennen FaerieBane |
Posted - 07 Jul 2005 : 23:47:47 quote: Originally posted by ode904
I'm intrested too. If someone could kindly place a link here to those pages, which contain grammars of Elven or so on .
Could you imagine that? All of is Faerun junkies speaking a language that united us all? Hah! That's like alignment tongue.
C-Fb |
ode904 |
Posted - 07 Jul 2005 : 22:35:05 I'm intrested too. If someone could kindly place a link here to those pages, which contain grammars of Elven or so on . |
|
|