| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| Razz |
Posted - 14 Jan 2013 : 19:40:04
It is well aware that in most cases you must be within one step of the alignment of your patron deity if you're a divine caster. (Sune's and the Elven pantheon's paladins and Veil of Cyric and Heretic of the Faith feats ignore this).
But what about non-divine casters? I have a player who is an air Genasi sorcerer whose personality and outlook on his life reflects Selune's dominion over wanderers, questers, and navigators. He is a Sorcerer with the Stormborn bloodline (using PF rules) but he is Lawful Good and she is Chaotic Good.
Is he still allowed to have her as his patron even though he is not a divine caster? |
| 11 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| JohnLynch |
Posted - 18 Jan 2013 : 08:53:13
quote:
Originally posted by Razz
Actually check the PRD for Pathfinder. Clerics in PF do follow the same one step rule.
Sorry. I meant specifically for Paladins. My original post could have been clearer. |
| Mystic Lemur |
Posted - 18 Jan 2013 : 01:06:37
I admit I've always liked the idea of a Paladin of Bane or Asmodeus, amusing not the least because they would have an aura of evil. However, I don't see a Paladin of Bane lasting long without falling. |
| Ayrik |
Posted - 15 Jan 2013 : 15:37:23
Some of the Faerūnian deities tolerate a wider range of behaviours among their priests. Others have stricter requirements and will not accept any perceived transgressions; a few constantly test the faith of their priests and weed out all those who falter. Chaotic deities more often embrace faithful across multiple alignments, Lawful deities tend to prefer uncompromised sources of faith with a unified and absolute alignment.
Selūne seems to be a somewhat liberal goddess, especially since she governs such a diverse medley of otherwise-unrelated portfolios and believers. Rules for her priesthood would likely vary considerably in each temple, region, and order.
Tempus seems interested in anyone who is ferocious and warlike. Militant or barbaric, dedicated to living and dying by the sword, or by the axe, or by the pointy stick, or by the siege engine, or by grimacing tooth and nail, it hardly matters to Tempus because more sects and orders of his faith competing and conflicting with each other means more strife and war and power to sustain him.
Tyr is utterly intolerant of justice, specifically his brand of Lawful Good justice. His priests are invariably LG-aligned, and they see that all those who defy Tyr's decrees, his moral and ethical principles, will be brought to face justice. |
| Markustay |
Posted - 15 Jan 2013 : 14:47:37
Personally, I ignore all that. I think it is an artificial layer added so gamers don't 'break something' (getting all the benefits of an evil priest without the downside of being a pariah).
I look at it this way - if you are crazy enough to think 'tyranny' is good (because humans are just stupid animals who need to be controlled for their own safety), then there is no reason in the world Bane would not welcome you with open arms.
And by the same token, we have a canon example of greedy priests of Selune (IIRC) selling 'favors' to followers. What are those things called again?* When the priesthood claims you can 'buy your way into Heaven'? Anyhow, seems pretty obvious to me that a priest can get away with a lot without their god even noticing (or caring).
*Indulgences (I Googled real quick - I think thats it) |
| Razz |
Posted - 15 Jan 2013 : 12:56:01
quote:
Originally posted by JohnLynch
quote:
Originally posted by Mapolq
As it was said above, the one-step rule applies only to actual church members/special devotees of that deity (in rules, anyone who receives spells from said deity, I think)
In Pathfinder there are no restrictions on the alignment of the deity you worship, RAW. As such a true neutral deity could have a LG Paladin RAW if you find a DM willing to let you create that character (I'm one such DM). Technically you could also have a paladin to a CE deity, but I'm personally not willing to go quite that far.
Actually check the PRD for Pathfinder. Clerics in PF do follow the same one step rule. |
| JohnLynch |
Posted - 15 Jan 2013 : 09:00:19
quote:
Originally posted by Mapolq
As it was said above, the one-step rule applies only to actual church members/special devotees of that deity (in rules, anyone who receives spells from said deity, I think)
In Pathfinder there are no restrictions on the alignment of the deity you worship, RAW. As such a true neutral deity could have a LG Paladin RAW if you find a DM willing to let you create that character (I'm one such DM). Technically you could also have a paladin to a CE deity, but I'm personally not willing to go quite that far. |
| Mapolq |
Posted - 15 Jan 2013 : 00:44:58
As it was said above, the one-step rule applies only to actual church members/special devotees of that deity (in rules, anyone who receives spells from said deity, I think), with the exceptions also noted above.
That said, I think the one-step rule is a terrible over-simplification and I don't use it in my games. The alignment system itself is such a simplification that I don't like to limit my players based on it, ever. That doesn't mean I hate it, I think it has its purposes, but sometimes it just gets in the way. About the one-step rule again, sure, it makes some sense most of the time, but there's plenty of exceptions (some of which are in the rules, many that are not). For example, it's very much possible to follow the dogmas of Waukeen or Mystra and still have any alignment (check the Scions of Arrabar trilogy for a throughly LG Waukeenar character, for example). |
| MrHedgehog |
Posted - 15 Jan 2013 : 00:16:56
Sune and Selune also have Paladins as well as Monks in 3e |
| Razz |
Posted - 14 Jan 2013 : 23:47:45
Ok I figured as much. That non divine casters can't really stretch the rules, they have to adhere as close as possible to the faith whereas someone else can just live their life more freely with dedication to a patron but have more liberal views on how they go about their life in such a way.
Thanks for the references, that does help. |
| Kentinal |
Posted - 14 Jan 2013 : 20:46:15
The one step rule appeared to indicate Clerics, not followers as such that were not. Non Divine casters do not need to look to a deity granted spells. |
| Jeremy Grenemyer |
Posted - 14 Jan 2013 : 20:24:37
Looking at the FRCS (page 290), I see that it indicates "A character's choice of a patron deity does not create any special obligations for that character." It goes on to state such choices reflect a character's favorite deity, one that matches the character's values, self-image and ambitions.
In the same book, the Arcane Devotee prestige class is listed (page 40). This PrC is for arcane spellcasters that are devoted to a particular faith. In the requirements, it's indicated an Arcane Devotee need only have a deity as a patron to which they wish to be a devotee of. There is no one-step alignment restriction listed.
It reads to me like the character would be OK to pick Selune as a patron. |
|
|
